Wondering Which Coffee is Right for You?
Find your perfect match!
Not sure which coffee to start with? We’ve put together this quick guide to help you find the roast that best matches your taste, brewing style, and caffeine preferences. Whether you’re new to specialty coffee or just new to us, this will point you in the right direction.
If you like easy-drinking, all-day coffees
Try: Happy Medium, Jacob’s Audible, or Afraid of the Dark
These smooth, chocolatey medium roasts are customer favorites for good reason — mellow, balanced, and endlessly drinkable.
Try: Happy Medium, Jacob’s Audible, or Afraid of the Dark
These smooth, chocolatey medium roasts are customer favorites for good reason — mellow, balanced, and endlessly drinkable.
If you like light roasts with a hint of fruitiness
Try: Ritual at Dawn
This one’s bright, light, and slightly fruity — perfect for coffee lovers who prefer their brew on the delicate side.
Try: Ritual at Dawn
This one’s bright, light, and slightly fruity — perfect for coffee lovers who prefer their brew on the delicate side.
If you make espresso at home
Try: Happy Medium, Afraid of the Dark, or Dark Passenger
These blends shine in espresso machines, with bold, smooth flavors and great crema.
Try: Happy Medium, Afraid of the Dark, or Dark Passenger
These blends shine in espresso machines, with bold, smooth flavors and great crema.
If you’re cutting back on caffeine
Try: The Devil Made Me Decaf
It’s just as smooth and flavorful as the real deal. Want a half-caf option? Blend it with Happy Medium for the best of both worlds.
Try: The Devil Made Me Decaf
It’s just as smooth and flavorful as the real deal. Want a half-caf option? Blend it with Happy Medium for the best of both worlds.
If you want your coffee to give back
Try: Happy Medium and Jacob’s Audible
All our coffees support mental health nonprofits — but these two go the extra mile. Happy Medium supports Nashville Therapy Pets, and Jacob’s Audible donates to the autism nonprofit founded in Jacob’s name.
Try: Happy Medium and Jacob’s Audible
All our coffees support mental health nonprofits — but these two go the extra mile. Happy Medium supports Nashville Therapy Pets, and Jacob’s Audible donates to the autism nonprofit founded in Jacob’s name.
If you want a no-brainer best-seller
Try: Happy Medium or Afraid of the Dark
Our most popular blends. Smooth. Flavorful. Never bitter. Start here and thank us later.
Try: Happy Medium or Afraid of the Dark
Our most popular blends. Smooth. Flavorful. Never bitter. Start here and thank us later.
If you like to try new things
Try: Designated Driver, Booze Hound (when available), or Motley Brew
Designated Driver is a dark, velvety roast with intriguing pipe tobacco notes (no ash, we promise). Booze Hound is bourbon-infused and unforgettable. Motley Brew rotates regularly — always something new to obsess over.
Try: Designated Driver, Booze Hound (when available), or Motley Brew
Designated Driver is a dark, velvety roast with intriguing pipe tobacco notes (no ash, we promise). Booze Hound is bourbon-infused and unforgettable. Motley Brew rotates regularly — always something new to obsess over.
If you take your coffee with cream
Try: Happy Medium, Jacob’s Audible, or Afraid of the Dark
These blends hold up beautifully to cream without losing their smooth, chocolate-forward flavor.
Try: Happy Medium, Jacob’s Audible, or Afraid of the Dark
These blends hold up beautifully to cream without losing their smooth, chocolate-forward flavor.
If you want bold, dark, and full-bodied
Try: Dark Passenger
Our deepest, darkest roast. Heavy-bodied, low-acid, rich and brooding — but never bitter.
Try: Dark Passenger
Our deepest, darkest roast. Heavy-bodied, low-acid, rich and brooding — but never bitter.
If you like cold brew
Try: Afraid of the Dark
This smooth blend makes excellent cold brew - low acid, rich in flavor, and strong enough to stand up to ice, milk, and sweeteners.
If you’re new to specialty coffee
Try: Happy Medium or Jacob’s Audible
Approachable, smooth, and crowd-pleasing - these blends are great for easing into the world of fresh-roasted coffee without getting overwhelmed.
If you’re switching from pods or grocery store coffee
Try: Happy Medium or Afraid of the Dark
These are massive upgrades in flavor and freshness - without being too wild. A perfect first step into real-deal coffee.
If you like your coffee strong, but not bitter
Try: Afraid of the Dark or Dark Passenger. Both bring the bold without the bite. Think deep flavor, not burnt aftertaste.
If you want something travel-ready
Try: Any of our coffees in one-pot packs. Pre-measured, resealable, and easy to tuck in your carry-on. Perfect for hotel rooms, cabins, and on-the-go brewing.
If you’re looking for something gift-able
Try our gift boxes, sampler packs, and bundles. Whether it’s for a birthday, holiday, or just because, these make thoughtful (and highly drinkable) gifts.
Still not sure? Don’t overthink it - you really can’t go wrong. All of our coffees are small-batch, freshly roasted, and super smooth (never bitter). Start with what sounds good and let your taste buds lead the way.
No matter what you choose, you’re getting premium coffee with a purpose - and we are glad you are here!
