Side Quest – Sugar Cookie tastes a little like someone figured out how to dunk a warm, buttery sugar cookie into your coffee without leaving a single crumb behind. Finally, progress.

It’s part of our Side Quest flavored series, where we take great coffee and add thoughtfully chosen flavors meant to complement the cup, not bury it. This one layers buttery vanilla and fresh-baked cookie flavor over smooth, carefully roasted coffee for a cup that’s simple, cozy, and way more interesting than “vanilla coffee.”

Think a soft sugar cookie fresh from the oven: buttery edges, plenty of vanilla, and that warm, just-baked flavor that somehow makes eating three cookies seem perfectly reasonable. Those bakery notes settle right into the coffee while still letting the coffee itself come through.

Flavor-wise, expect buttery sugar cookie, warm vanilla, and a smooth coffee finish.

Drink it black and the cookie and vanilla notes come through as aroma and flavor—not added sweetness—so you get all the sugar-cookie vibes without actually adding sugar to your cup.

Add a little cream and it gets even more convincing. The cream rounds out the coffee and brings forward that buttery vanilla flavor until your morning mug starts doing a pretty solid impression of the bakery case.

Whether you’re already firmly on Team Flavored Coffee or just looking for an excuse to wander away from your usual cup, Side Quest is your permission slip to take the scenic route.

Achievement unlocked: cookies for breakfast. No crumbs, no witnesses.

This coffee is roasted in small batches and sent right to you, so it’s fresh. Our air-roasting method removes the chaff before it can burn, which is why our coffee comes out smooth and flavorful, never bitter. And because we believe mental health matters, a portion of every purchase helps support mental health nonprofits.